Second in a four-part special report
At 1 a.m., the bell rang. You Mi Kim rushed with eight other
Korean masseuses to the barren front lobby of Sun Spa in San
Francisco. The women lined up on an L-shaped couch in their
lingerie and waited for the customer to choose.
[Podcast:
Meredith May with a South Korean woman who counsels sex
trafficking victims. ]
"Don't pick me, don't pick me," You Mi thought,
forcing a smile.
Less than a year earlier, she'd been a college student in
South Korea, only to be tricked into leaving her home by sex
traffickers offering promises of a high-paying hostess job.
Desperate for a way out of her $40,000 debt, You Mi bit. Now,
she was at the end of yet another 15-hour shift of forced sex.
The man examined You Mi's petite frame, her brown eyes and
her dark hair, which fell like silk to her shoulders.
He pointed at her.
You Mi led him from the lobby to one of the four upstairs
massage rooms and told him to shower in the bathtub behind a
curtain in the corner.
"This is my first time," he said.
It was a line You Mi heard daily inside Sun Spa.
The man was athletic, muscular. After showering, he led her
to the bed and stretched out on his stomach. You Mi began
massaging his shoulders.
Suddenly, he jumped off the bed, declared he didn't need a
massage and yanked off her white camisole.
He threw her to the mattress and forced himself on her,
pulling her hair and twisting her small body in so many ways
that she screamed in pain.
Then the man's eyes went blank. He began choking her. She
heard sounds of pleasure escape his throat. He seemed to be
enjoying it.
The manager burst through the door. "What's going
on?" she shouted in Korean.
"Help me!" You Mi gasped.
The man released his grip. The manager turned her attention
to the customer.
"I'm sorry she disappointed you," she said,
refunding his $50. A disgruntled john might tip off the police.
The man pocketed the money, turned and walked out the front
door.
Of all the degradations You Mi endured while forced to work
as a California sex slave in 2003, this was the worst. In an
instant it became clear: Her life amounted to $50. The manager
ordered her back to work.
After her attack, You Mi did the only thing she could think
of to survive. She wiped away the tears and smiled for her next
customer.
For nearly a year, You Mi was caught in a sex-trafficking
triangle -- starting in South Korea, one of the world's leading
importers and exporters of sex slaves, and stretching to the
exploding Asian outcall market of Los Angeles and then to the
Asian massage-parlor mecca on the West Coast: San Francisco.
She would be forced to have sex with dozens of men a week in
seedy massage parlors, apartments and hotel rooms. She would
live under the watchful eye of guards and surveillance cameras,
reminded constantly that her family back in South Korea would be
harmed if she ran.
She would work in brothels with blacked-out windows and
double metal security doors, allowed outside only under the
escort of crooked taxi drivers working for the traffickers who
drove her to sex appointments. She would also be trapped
culturally, unable to speak more than a few basic sentences in
English, unaware of where she was and dependent on her captors
for food and shelter.
To traffickers, 22-year-old You Mi was the perfect victim: a
small-town girl in financial trouble. She gave her trust, and in
return her life went horribly wrong, terribly fast.
Along a crooked hillside market in the South Korean port city of
Busan, vendors gut fish and wash chicken feet, getting ready for
the morning shopping rush.
This is You Mi's hometown, also known as the San Francisco of
South Korea. Situated on the southeastern tip of the country,
Busan also has steep streets, summer beach tourists and even a
white version of the Golden Gate Bridge.
Busan is also the birthplace of South Korea's sex industry,
where Japanese troops built the first brothels after invading
the country in 1904.
But the selling of Korean women goes back to the 15th
century, when wealthy men bought educated Kisaeng girls to live
in their homes and entertain them with song, dance, cooking and
sometimes sex.
Today, sex work accounts for 4 percent of the country's gross
domestic product, according to government reports. Prostitution
brings $21 billion a year -- more than electricity and gas
combined. There are an estimated 330,000 sex workers, 80,000
brothels and 69 red-light districts in a country the size of
Indiana.
Busan is infamous for Wan Wol Dong, a maze of dark alleys
where women are on display in row upon row of "glass
houses." A peculiar Korean invention, a glass house is
about the size of a parking space, with glass walls on three
sides and a mirrored back wall concealing a private bedroom.
Women sit on chairs or chaises or on the floor inside,
illuminated by red lights that cast a pink glow.
For about $75, men strolling or driving by have their pick of
older women in silk bathrobes, younger women in hot pants and
even preteens in ballerina skirts and heart-shaped bodices.
Glass houses are just one item on South Korea's sexual menu.
Sex is sold out of bars, restaurants, coffee shops, barbershops,
tearooms, karaoke bars, saunas, massage parlors, over the
Internet, in skin-care shops and hair salons, in computer rooms
called PC bangs, in "love motels" and in nightclubs
near U.S. military bases.
Even something as simple as ordering coffee has been
sexualized. "Ticket tabang" girls make home deliveries
with thermoses of coffee to sex-seeking callers.
While a 2004 South Korean law targeting pimps and buyers has
slowed foot traffic in the open-air sex markets, early signs
indicate that the crackdown has had the unintended effect of
fueling international sex trafficking. Pimps simply go online or
overseas -- mainly to Australia and the United States -- where
demand is high and risk is low. They recruit in cities like
Seoul and Busan, where most of the country's universities are
located.
When You Mi was a little girl, her family -- like many others
-- partly supported itself on the sex trade. For one year, her
mother managed a room salon, where women in skirt suits pour
drinks, sing karaoke, dance and, if asked, retreat to a private
room to have sex with customers. Considered playpens for the
wealthy, room salons attract businessmen who spend the
equivalent of $1,000 for a few hours at a table, and seal their
corporate deals with sexual entertainment instead of handshakes.
The room salon was off-limits to You Mi and her younger
sister, although sometimes her mother would ask her to fetch
dried squid and other snacks for the family business.
Mostly You Mi spent her days at elementary school and her
afternoons perfecting her skill at a Korean version of
double-Dutch jump rope. She spent so much time jumping over two
elastic ropes stretched by two of her girlfriends that she
developed large calf muscles and the nickname
"Drumstick."
She dreamed of becoming a policewoman.
You Mi's family lived in one of the poorer neighborhoods of
Busan. The family budget got even smaller when her mother's room
salon went out of business, and all they had was her father's
carpentry income. Her mother tried opening a restaurant, selling
boiled eggs and sticky rice as a street vendor, and running a
karaoke bar, but those ventures also failed. You Mi and her
sister knew never to ask their parents for spending money
because there never was any to spare.
Money was tight for all the families in her neighborhood, so
You Mi never felt deprived. But in 2001, when her family had to
struggle to come up with nearly $6,000 to send her to a
university closer to the city, she realized her family was poor.
At college for the first time, she was surrounded by friends who
came from the glittering beach high-rises.
They knew things, like how to wear makeup, which bars poured
the strongest soju -- the Korean version of vodka -- and which
hairdressers had the longest waiting lists.
And they had something You Mi had never seen before -- credit
cards.
A friend explained to You Mi that she could buy things
without cash. A magic card, You Mi thought.
She had to have one. After school, You Mi took the bus to
Seomyeon, a shopping district jammed with neon-covered
multistory department stores and an enormous underground mall
beneath eight lanes of traffic.
A street vendor was eager to sign her up for a Samsung credit
card. She filled out the application truthfully, except for the
part about her home address. She knew her mother would not
approve, so You Mi put down her friend's address instead.
The vendor didn't explain debt accrual and interest rates to
You Mi.
As she waited for her card to arrive, she began to fantasize
about a future with buying power. She dreamed of changing from a
caterpillar to a butterfly -- from an awkward girl in a school
uniform to a glamorous sophisticate wrapped in fashionable
clothes, jewelry and perfume.
Getting a credit card would make her a woman.
The clock wouldn't move fast enough. Finally, at 3 p.m., You Mi
bolted out the university doors and headed for the subterranean
shopping mall, her new credit card in her pocket.
She and five friends from school descended a staircase from
the sidewalk down to the mall. Hundreds of girls walking arm in
arm crowded the halls, laughing, shopping and talking on cell
phones. Store upon store, no larger than walk-in closets,
offered a paradise targeted at You Mi's generation: metallic
handbags, low-rise jeans, high-heeled boots, skin-care creams,
digital cameras and American-style sneakers.
You Mi wasted no time. She bought a handbag, shoes and a new
jacket. She went to a wall of ATM machines and pulled out a
couple of hundred more so she could get her hair done at a
salon.
She felt grown up. She felt popular. When she invited her
group of friends to dinner and drinks at a soju bar, they all
said yes.
By the day's end, she had spent the equivalent of $600. She
felt a pang of worry about how she would pay the money back
without a job. But a week later, the pang had subsided. It was
Friday, and her friends wanted to go out again.
Soon, the Friday outings became a regular habit for You Mi
and her companions. Her wealthy friends rarely offered to pay
after the pork cutlets and kimchi were eaten, but You Mi
relished her newfound generosity and didn't complain.
It was easy for her to get sucked into the shopping culture
in Busan. Fashion is a major cultural preoccupation for South
Koreans, who crowd the glittering neon shopping districts at
night to window-shop and people-watch. Designer labels create
the dividing lines among social classes, and women dress in fur,
cashmere and heels just to run errands. Street beggars are
nonexistent, and poverty is considered a mortal sin.
Such intense pressure to acquire "American luxury
goods" puts the average South Korean family in $30,000
credit card debt.
Once You Mi started wearing nicer clothes, she noticed people
were more willing to be her friend.
She bought so much that she had to sneak her purchases into
her room at night. When her mother questioned some of the new
clothes, You Mi explained that her new college friends were
letting her borrow them.
She could keep her mother at bay, but not the Samsung credit
card division. In South Korea, cardholders can be taken to court
if they are 90 days late on a payment. It's not uncommon for
credit card companies to enter homes and red-tag the
possessions, even repossess the home itself.
After a year, in 2002, You Mi owed $10,000. Samsung cut her
off. So You Mi called one of the dozens of moneylenders
advertising quick cash in the free weekly newspapers, and he
gave her $2,000 at 25 percent interest, plus $140 monthly fees.
You Mi was stuck. She quit school to get a job selling tokens
and drinks in Lucky 7, a gambling hall, so she could start
making payments on the card.
You Mi told her parents she was taking a year off to raise
money for tuition. Her younger sister was starting college that
year, and her parents couldn't afford to send both girls. They
were proud of their eldest daughter for being so responsible.
Although You Mi earned $650 a month during her year at Lucky
7, she was still spending. She turned to moneylenders five more
times to get increments of $2,000 to finance shopping trips and
nightclub outings with her friends. She knew her behavior was
reckless, but she was addicted to money's power -- the attention
it drew from friends and the feeling of generosity it gave her.
With each passing day, she worried that Samsung would take
her family's house.
Then You Mi took out a second credit card to pay off all the
loans.
She was too ashamed to tell her friends or family about her
mounting debt. She wanted to fix it herself without burdening
anyone. Two years after getting the original credit card, her
combined debt hit $40,000.
You Mi found an empty table at a downtown cafe and opened to the
job pages of the free weekly newspapers. It was January 2003.
Before her were hundreds of ads for sex workers: escorts,
room salon girls, masseuses, exotic dancers and outcall
services. Some offered jobs in America, Japan and Australia as
"waitresses and models."
A year at the gambling hall had done little to erase her
debt. High-paying jobs are limited for Korean women, and nearly
nonexistent for young women without a college degree, like You
Mi. The idea that college is a place for women to meet eligible
husbands is still widely held in a country where it's rare to
see a female politician, judge or professor.
It's common knowledge that the sex trade employs many women
in Korea, yet people rarely speak of it. By middle school, some
girls are already financing their wardrobes by selling
themselves over the Internet.
So by fall 2002, You Mi began to wonder whether she was
willing to do the unthinkable: sell her body.
Like most girls in South Korea, You Mi knew not to answer the
ads for "coffee delivery girls" who work in ticket
tabangs, the dreariest and lowest-paying job in the sex
industry. The ticket tabang, the poor-man's sex outlet in rural
farmland areas, attracts teenage girls who are just starting in
the sex business, and who can be bought for as little as $20 an
hour.
She also didn't want to be a "juicy girl," forced
to live and work in one of the many nightclubs that cater to the
36,000 American soldiers in South Korea. If the juicy girls
don't persuade soldiers to buy them enough $20 drinks in a
night, the club owner requires them to have sex with customers
-- the equivalent of five drinks.
You Mi looked over the ads for room salons. She knew that the
first round inside a room salon, pouring drinks, is never
enough. Women always have to go to the second round -- having
sex -- if the customer asks for it. And the customer always
does.
The longer You Mi searched, the more it became clear to her
that she couldn't stomach the thought of having sex with
strangers for money.
After looking for a week, You Mi found on the Internet what
appeared to be the perfect solution.
"Work in an American room salon. Make $10,000 a month.
Very gentle. No touching. No second round."
She was dubious. She had never heard of a sex-free room salon
before, but maybe in the United States things were different.
You Mi did the math. She could work for six months, pay off
the credit card and moneylenders, and use the remaining $20,000
to fly back to Korea and re-enroll in college, maybe even get
her own apartment. Easy.
The man who answered the phone said he needed to meet her in
person. At a coffee shop in Busan, the broker looked at her body
and face and said she could have the job if she wanted it.
He was short on details, but told her she would pour drinks
for men in room salons in Koreatown in Los Angeles.
"Is it gentle, no touching with customers like the ad
says?" she asked.
"Yes, this is an American room salon; it's different
than the ones in Korea, there's no sex," he assured her.
You Mi wanted it to be true. She needed it to be true.
She didn't have a visa or a passport. And she certainly
didn't have the $7,000 fee the broker told her it would take to
get her to Los Angeles through unofficial channels.
"Don't worry about that," he said. "You can
pay it back later from your earnings."
You Mi was frightened about leaving home with underground
travel brokers. Her mind, though, was consumed with her mounting
debt. The next day, she called the broker and said yes.
She told her younger sister she was going to America for
work, but to keep it a secret from her parents, who would never
grant her permission to work abroad. You Mi told her parents she
was going to Seoul to be a golf caddy -- one of the few legal
women's jobs that bring hefty tips from rich men.
She planned to tell them the truth after she paid off her
debts.
You Mi was instructed to take passport photos and give them
to a man named Kevin in Seoul. The broker drove her to the city,
and two days later, You Mi had her passport.
A different broker took her to the airport in Incheon, where
she joined another Korean woman, a room-salon worker on her
third trip to America. The broker handed them tickets to Mexico
City.
"You told us we were going to America," protested
You Mi, who did not know a stopover was part of the plan.
The broker was exasperated.
"Didn't the broker in Busan explain this to you? Why are
you asking me all these questions?"
You Mi felt something wasn't right, but the promise of
financial freedom beckoned.
She swallowed her worry and boarded the plane.
You Mi buckled her seat belt and turned to her flying companion.
The older woman looked the other way and said nothing.
The plane stopped in Japan, Los Angeles and finally Mexico
City. It was February 2003. You Mi had been up for more than 24
hours, and everything seemed blurry. She had never been on a
plane, she had never heard Spanish spoken, and she was starting
to doubt her decision to come in the first place.
At the airport, a Korean man was waiting for You Mi and her
flying companion. He treated them to a meal, and gave them $500
each. You Mi didn't realize it, but that spending money would be
added to the debt she owed her traffickers. Then he went to the
ticket counter and asked in Spanish for two tickets to Tijuana.
A second Korean man met the women at the Tijuana airport,
drove them to a hotel on the border and checked them into the
same room. He took their passports and told them to stay in the
motel.
You Mi did as she was told.
Four days later, the second Korean man returned to the motel
and handed You Mi a visa with a photo of a woman who looked a
lot like herself.
"Memorize her name and information," he ordered.
The man said they were going to be driven through the San
Ysidro border checkpoint with the fake documents. Two drivers
were ready -- one for You Mi, and one for the other woman.
"It's dangerous," he warned, "so be careful,
and don't shake or look nervous because you'll draw suspicion
from the customs agents."
He told You Mi to take only a few outfits from her suitcase
and carry them in a smaller bag so it would appear that she was
returning from a brief Mexican vacation.
You Mi was confused. She turned to her traveling companion
and tried again to figure things out.
"Why do we have to cross illegally if we have
passports?" she asked, referring to the passport that
traffickers in Seoul had created for her.
The woman explained that Koreans need visas to get into the
United States, but not into Mexico or Canada. Because it's
difficult to obtain legitimate U.S. visas in Korea, it's easier
to fly just outside the California border and sneak in.
"You've come this far," the woman said. "Why
don't you just cross?"
The Story
How we reported the series
San Francisco Chronicle reporter Meredith May and
photographer Deanne Fitzmaurice reported this story from South
Korea, the U.S.-Mexican border, from Koreatown in Los Angeles
and from San Francisco.
The story was told by You Mi Kim to May through a Korean
interpreter and is You Mi's version of events. The shadowy
nature of the sex-trafficking industry made it difficult to
locate traffickers and co-workers who were willing to go on the
record to corroborate You Mi's story.
The Chronicle verified the locations of the apartments and
brothels where You Mi said she worked. May and Fitzmaurice also
went to her hometown in Busan, South Korea, and spent time in
her neighborhood, at her university, the casino where she worked
and in the shopping malls where she went into credit card debt.
You Mi's attorney shared her knowledge of You Mi's case.
This year, You Mi also recounted her story for the U.S.
government, which granted her a special visa for trafficking
victims, given only to those who can prove they were enslaved
through "force, fraud or coercion." The government's
decision was based on interviews with You Mi's attorney, and on
You Mi's written story, which was translated into English by the
same interpreter who worked with The Chronicle.
You Mi's story was bolstered by May's interviews with more
than 100 people over a 10-month period, including female
sex-trafficking victims, current and former sex workers, men who
pay for sexual services, federal sex-trafficking investigators,
owners of sex establishments, U.S. Border Patrol agents, customs
agents, U.S. and Korean government officials, university
researchers, attorneys and numerous social workers who provide
shelter, support and legal aid to trafficking victims.
May's reporting was supplemented by numerous court documents
and research papers. She attended sex-trafficking conferences,
sat through court hearings and attended a Bay Area
police-training seminar on human trafficking. She went inside
five alleged San Francisco brothels with Mayor Gavin Newsom and
city health-and-safety inspection teams, and witnessed
customers, brothel managers and sex workers answering police
questions.
May met You Mi Kim in September 2005. Over the course of 10
months, May interviewed You Mi with the help of a professional
interpreter provided by Asian Pacific Islander Legal Outreach in
San Francisco.
To research the sex culture and trafficking industry in South
Korea, May interviewed Bong Hyup Chung, the government's top
sex-trafficking official at the South Korean Ministry of Gender
Equality and Family. May and Fitzmaurice met women in sex-worker
shelters, and visited with more than a dozen agencies that offer
sanctuary and social support to trafficked women. In South
Korea, May interviewed two women who had been trafficked to
California and one to Japan. She spoke with a woman from the
former Soviet Union and several from the Philippines who were
trafficked into South Korea. She also interviewed six South
Korean women who had been forced into the sex trade within South
Korea.
May and Fitzmaurice reported from the red-light districts of
Seoul and Busan, where women are on display in glass rooms.
There, they spoke with Korean military police on patrol, and
"fishers," elderly women who beckon customers into the
rooms. They interviewed U.S. soldiers in sex clubs near the
demilitarized zone, and spoke with the "juicy girls"
inside who are hired to entice men to buy them $20 drinks and
pay for sex.
May and Fitzmaurice visited businesses that secretly offer
sex, including a male-only drinking club called a "room
salon," a coffee shop with delivery service called a
"ticket tabang," and a "PC bang," an
adult-only computer center with private rooms where men have
online sex or make arrangements to meet women in person. They
spoke with the owners, workers and customers.
At the Korean Institute of Criminology, May tracked down
reports depicting the size and scope of the South Korean sex
trade and trafficking industry, which were translated with the
help of an interpreter. Translators helped May peruse the want
ads in Korean newspapers that are used by sex traffickers to
lure women.
Like most of the women May interviewed, You Mi was able to
recall the exact wording of the newspaper ad that prompted her
to seek employment in America. Conversations that You Mi had
with traffickers and her traveling companion were based on You
Mi's recollections.
In Korea, May interviewed attaches with the U.S. Immigration
and Customs Enforcement office, who investigate and help
prosecute Korean sex-trafficking rings linked to the United
States.
Story by Meredith May And Photographs by Deanne
Fitzmaurice Chronicle Staff E-mail Meredith May at mmay@sfchronicle.com.
Original link: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2006/10/08/MNGAULL53D1.DTL